Here is what I came up with using Identifont: http://www.identifont.com/list?1+id+0+7WF+13+IF+12+6ST+12+5O2+11+BHH+11+EF7+11+8N0+11+2ZS+11+9JM+11+9JI+11+9JK+11+9JJ+11+5D5+10+68G+10+60K+10+6B5+10+CF+10+4DD+10+96Q+10+50W+10+6WO+10+4DI+10+5GU+10+642+10+46K+10+RU+10+5IO+10+7P3+10+23N+9+7LR+9
Hope that helps
Can you help me identity this font? I'm also looking for a free source for a baseball dingbat.