OK...I don't have a pic, but I know what this font looks like. I saw it first on 1001 Free Fonts, but after searching the site in my sleep-deprived state, I didn't see it again.

The font looks like letters sinking into water at sunset...very esoteric and moody, Creature from the Black Lagoon-esque.

Anyone have any ideas what it could be?

Sunset? There is a font called that believe it or not:

http://www.haroldsfonts.com/sunset.html

You know, I did a search for "Sunset" and nothing came up. Strange.

Because it is not sunset, but "sunset__.ttf" that you have to ask Big Brother for. That is, including the quotation marks.