I need to find out what this is...I thought it was a modified Athletic Regular, but there are some differences that make me think that's not the one...Your opinions?

OK, with the picture this time...I had it too big

Try fattening and filling Princetown or as free alternate a font called Allstar … don't know if that's a knock-off.

Yep, I agree. I had just tried that when I noticed you had replied, and I think it will work...Thank you